![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
eumeliaCaster Semenya on suicide watch.
Colour me unsurprised and royally pissed off.
I've been keeping up to date on the story ever since Germaine Greer's transphobic comments regarding the affair.
I have about ten tabs open with articles and blog posts all talking about Semenya.
Many people are talking about the issue, as well they should.
To me, it reads as a cautionary tale to those women who dare to be exceptional, who dare to toe the line of the gender assigned to them at birth, of women who cannot (visibly) be intimidated by a man.
We will crush you, if you dare. The same goes to any gender non-conformist. Caster Semenya had the misfortune to be a good runner, she beat the European competition (in Berlin no less) and was then (almost literally) dissected in public to make sure that she didn't have an "unfair advantage".
The intersection of sexism, racism, colonialism, gender essentialism and the problematic state of women athletes in track and field sports all seemed to coalesce in the most destructive way possible on this woman, whose life (not to mention career) has gone down the drain.
The public eye, the policing of what is considered appropriate identity will kill you dead if you dare step out of line and show that you are good at what you do.
Your identity, that thing you spent so much time moulding and attuning and making your own is shattered by the fact that the medical institute insists that we are as our bodies say we are.
Biology is destiny.
Various hair products, plastic surgery, body-modification parlours and trans people who go through hormone therapy and sex reassignment surgery (top and/or bottom) tell a different story.
A woman's body is up for public consumption. Add racism into the mix and you have the masses demanding she be made "presentable".
It was the beginning of the end when I saw that Semenya had been made over. Her androgyny (pic before makeover) became a source of contention in the aftermath of her win. Moreover, the history of black women's bodies being forced to conform to Euro-centric beauty standards and the issue of how black femininity is culturally lesser than white femininity also raised the level of what Semenya needed to do in order to compensate, nay, publicly apologize for the fact that she's a masculine woman (pic after makeover).
In the article The Unforgivable Transgression of Being Caster Semenya, the author expands on the fact that black women (people of African descent in general) have historically been targeted as gender non-conformists, or even failures:
I'm loath to call gender essentialism imperialism, but different kinds of oppression do often come from the same place.
The policing of identities and bodies into the dominant world order and subjugating those identities and bodies in order to maintain that world order.
The gender binary is the world order.
And it kills.
What I really enjoyed in the article linked above was this paragraph:
One of the first things I learned when I became immersed in feminism was that society isn't the way it is, it's how we think it is.
Or rather, it's how we see ourselves as part of it.
That's why racism is systemic and there is a difference between a white person calling a black person a "nigger" and a black person calling a white person a "cracker".
The personal wound to either goes without saying, the history of the words are different and the affect that history has over our minds, bodies and social groups is severe.
Apartheid may be "over" in South Africa.
The disparity between those who Have and those who Have Not remains largely unchanged.
Caster Semenya is paying the price of being too good. Of being a woman whose biological body is now considered medically inapplicable to her gender. She may be Intersex (ETA: a fact that was leaked to the press before the results actually reached her. Classy), but she's a woman and she's being punished for not being female enough.
The article The Sad Saga of Caster Semenya writes:
Anyone's perception of self would be undone by the unbearable melancholy of one's identity being forcibly yoinked from pillar to post because of public demands, because gender is a prison even when you supposedly overcome it. Which is what woman athletes do of course, over come the infirmity of their weaker bodies - and they're still not considered to be worthy of same attention as men athletes, because the best woman will always be lesser than the medioce man. Suck on that Billie Jean King.
In conclusion:
Well, it doesn't end here. I hope I don't wake up tomorrow morning and discover that Caster Semenya ended her life because society deemed her unacceptable. The trauma is undeniable, the humiliation is beyond comprehension.
Gender essentialism continues to be the building block of oppression as we live it and no one is safe from the assault on the self if you dare to toe the line.
Failing in your gender, it's a killer, literally.
Colour me unsurprised and royally pissed off.
I've been keeping up to date on the story ever since Germaine Greer's transphobic comments regarding the affair.
I have about ten tabs open with articles and blog posts all talking about Semenya.
Many people are talking about the issue, as well they should.
To me, it reads as a cautionary tale to those women who dare to be exceptional, who dare to toe the line of the gender assigned to them at birth, of women who cannot (visibly) be intimidated by a man.
We will crush you, if you dare. The same goes to any gender non-conformist. Caster Semenya had the misfortune to be a good runner, she beat the European competition (in Berlin no less) and was then (almost literally) dissected in public to make sure that she didn't have an "unfair advantage".
The intersection of sexism, racism, colonialism, gender essentialism and the problematic state of women athletes in track and field sports all seemed to coalesce in the most destructive way possible on this woman, whose life (not to mention career) has gone down the drain.
The public eye, the policing of what is considered appropriate identity will kill you dead if you dare step out of line and show that you are good at what you do.
Your identity, that thing you spent so much time moulding and attuning and making your own is shattered by the fact that the medical institute insists that we are as our bodies say we are.
Biology is destiny.
Various hair products, plastic surgery, body-modification parlours and trans people who go through hormone therapy and sex reassignment surgery (top and/or bottom) tell a different story.
A woman's body is up for public consumption. Add racism into the mix and you have the masses demanding she be made "presentable".
It was the beginning of the end when I saw that Semenya had been made over. Her androgyny (pic before makeover) became a source of contention in the aftermath of her win. Moreover, the history of black women's bodies being forced to conform to Euro-centric beauty standards and the issue of how black femininity is culturally lesser than white femininity also raised the level of what Semenya needed to do in order to compensate, nay, publicly apologize for the fact that she's a masculine woman (pic after makeover).
In the article The Unforgivable Transgression of Being Caster Semenya, the author expands on the fact that black women (people of African descent in general) have historically been targeted as gender non-conformists, or even failures:
South Africans aren’t the only ones angrily comparing Semenya’s treatment to that of Saartjie Baartman, the nineteenth-century Khoisan woman who was exhibited throughout Europe as a sexualized monstrosity. White audiences guffawed, prodded and poked at her exposed body, which they laughingly demeaned as that of a “Hottentot Venus”: the inverse of European standards of beauty. Challenging Semenya’s femaleness, people now assert, is imperialism all over again.
I'm loath to call gender essentialism imperialism, but different kinds of oppression do often come from the same place.
The policing of identities and bodies into the dominant world order and subjugating those identities and bodies in order to maintain that world order.
The gender binary is the world order.
And it kills.
What I really enjoyed in the article linked above was this paragraph:
[I]nstead of insisting upon the naturalness of her gender, how about turning the question around and denaturalizing the world of gender segregated, performance-obsessed, commercially-driven sports, a world that can neither seem to do with or without excessive bodies like Semenya’s and their virtuosic performances?
The rush to compare Semenya to Saartjie Baartman, while obvious for nationalistic reasons, misses something crucial. Baartman was exhibited and castigated for what the imperialist eye took to be her abberant femininity. A better comparison here would be to the many trans bodies (like famed jazz pianist Billy Tipton[link added byeumelia) who have been disciplined and punished for their female masculinity.
One of the first things I learned when I became immersed in feminism was that society isn't the way it is, it's how we think it is.
Or rather, it's how we see ourselves as part of it.
That's why racism is systemic and there is a difference between a white person calling a black person a "nigger" and a black person calling a white person a "cracker".
The personal wound to either goes without saying, the history of the words are different and the affect that history has over our minds, bodies and social groups is severe.
Apartheid may be "over" in South Africa.
The disparity between those who Have and those who Have Not remains largely unchanged.
Caster Semenya is paying the price of being too good. Of being a woman whose biological body is now considered medically inapplicable to her gender. She may be Intersex (ETA: a fact that was leaked to the press before the results actually reached her. Classy), but she's a woman and she's being punished for not being female enough.
The article The Sad Saga of Caster Semenya writes:
[I]t is important to note here, critically, that Caster Semenya has always been a woman, has always defined herself as a woman, has lived her life as a woman, has to this date considered herself to be a woman, not transgendered, not a transman. It is critical to note this here as to understand both the statement to come as well as what a public scrutiny of gender is like.Emphasis mine
It is a horde of people thinking they have a right to decide where you belong with only an ignorant impression of your gender proclivities and expression with zero understanding of your internal sex. And their opinion is to be given credence over your own. Transpeople undergoing Harry-Benjamin style therapy for “permission” to transition know this feeling very well. It is humbling, infuriating, and leaves you feeling powerless and adrift.
And for her there’s no point at the end of it, just the threat of the removal of everything that has brought you joy, the threat that all of this can be taken away because you were suspicious. Now the public and an arbitrary standard noone fully understands can remove the one passion that has defined your life and remove from you the dream of a little girl (to compete, perchance to medal in the Olympic games, to bring honor to your country and family, and most importantly to yourself).
Gone in an instant.
Anyone's perception of self would be undone by the unbearable melancholy of one's identity being forcibly yoinked from pillar to post because of public demands, because gender is a prison even when you supposedly overcome it. Which is what woman athletes do of course, over come the infirmity of their weaker bodies - and they're still not considered to be worthy of same attention as men athletes, because the best woman will always be lesser than the medioce man. Suck on that Billie Jean King.
In conclusion:
Well, it doesn't end here. I hope I don't wake up tomorrow morning and discover that Caster Semenya ended her life because society deemed her unacceptable. The trauma is undeniable, the humiliation is beyond comprehension.
Gender essentialism continues to be the building block of oppression as we live it and no one is safe from the assault on the self if you dare to toe the line.
Failing in your gender, it's a killer, literally.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:20 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:29 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:20 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:37 pm (UTC)Over the past few years I've been trying to toe the line when it comes to my gender presentation. I'm cis and am very comfortable with id-ing as a woman, but the oppression... ach... so I've been doing stuff with hair mainly (shaving off the one on my head and leaving on the ones on my legs, etc.).
I've never encountered more polarised reactions to the Hair issue than anything else in my entire life.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:23 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:39 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:42 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:36 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:41 pm (UTC)I'm glad that others are glad... sorta... you know what I mean (I hope).
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:43 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:47 pm (UTC)Bleh.
This entire story has irked me from the moment I heard about the "gender test".
I really hope she'll be okay.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:50 pm (UTC)I linked your entry, if you don't mind. You wrote all I've been thinking for the last two weeks but haven't been able to set to paper without getting really upset.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 10:52 pm (UTC)If it's public, it's linkable.
Thanks for letting me know.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 11:08 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 11:37 pm (UTC)The university's website is web.up.ac.za and I'm looking for any kind of general mailing address that could be used to send something care-of.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 11:40 pm (UTC)http://www.chr.up.ac.za/about/staff.html
no subject
Date: 2009-09-15 11:55 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 05:05 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 12:06 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 06:15 am (UTC)Thanks for all that.
Will you keep us updated?
Thanks in advance!
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 12:06 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 12:08 pm (UTC)Thank you very much!
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 03:17 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 01:39 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 06:21 am (UTC)I shudder to think that we're on the same page as that pig, but the issue really is so much deeper.
I'm trying to be amazed at the nauseating way the News has been covering the "story", and it's just one big freak show.
Poor girl, she's only 18.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 01:50 am (UTC)p.s. i found your journal thanks to _yggdrasil
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 06:23 am (UTC)If it's public, it's shareable.
I'm glad this resonated for you.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 05:27 am (UTC)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMUIoO8eArA&feature=player_embedded#t=202
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 06:16 am (UTC)Thanks very much!
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 07:24 am (UTC)Leigh
no subject
Date: 2009-09-16 11:30 am (UTC)Beyond the issue of the standard of beauty, which is a detail that needs to be unpacked in its own right, the way she's been paraded in the media, the freak show spectacle of Semenya and of course invading her body in order to ascertain biological factors of identity is criminal.
The invasion of privacy is colossal.
I hope she makes it through this.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-19 04:06 am (UTC)I don't know why it's lit the fire in my belly so much with Semenya - gender issues have been on my radar for a while, as i've experienced dfiscrimination on being feminine since entering the queer community (mild stuff i know, but still makes me feel hurt & unwelcome).
I wish there was something i could do. If i can write past the brain fog i might try to at least add a voice of support and reason to comments on some of the articles about her, and perhaps write some letters to editors? If it's not too late to do so.
I wish there was some way to support her too. I skimmed your comments and saw someone mentioned perhaps writing to her - please let me know if this goes ahead, as i would like to do so. I don't know that it will help, but i'd like to let her know the whole world isn't mad and judging her cruely.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-21 05:11 pm (UTC)