![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
eumeliaThere is much to blog about, as much happened over the week and weekend, none of them particularly good.
Ah well, such is the state of the State.
As most of you know, Israel presents itself as a Homeland and Nation-State to the Jewish people, all well and good in principle I suppose.
A problem exists though in the notion that Israel has any say about how Jews relate to the State of Israel, or if they were to consider it a Homeland of any kind.
A 2000 year Diaspora is not so easily diminished by the fact that the State exists for 61 years or that the ideal of a Nation came about around the same time as all the others... it was a Spring, if I'm not mistaken.
Let it not be said that Israel doesn't share the arrogance of its neighbours when it comes to upholding what is the correct way for Jews to be Jews, and telling them so.
This week a new campaign targeting Diaspora Jews who have been lost to assimilation was launched.
As can be read in the article linked, the campaign is in aid of MASA, which is a partnership between the Jewish Agency and the Israeli Government that helps bring young Diaspora Jews to Israel for academic programs and things like that.
The propaganda machine of what goes on in programs such as MASA and Birthright aside, the new campaign is by far worse than any I've ever seen.
The video of the ad linked here or viewable right here:
I've translated the Hebrew for the benefit of my non-Hebrew speaking readers:
Now, the problem isn't the fact that this campaign exists, much to my annoyance, the problem is with the idea that Israel has basically created a campaign in which it calls people to tattle to this agency about Jewish people who aren't "Jewish" enough.
And when I say tattle, I mean that the number given in the ad isn't for curious Diaspora Jews to call and inquire, no-no, it is for us, Israeli Jews, to call that number and give the email, facebook, blog, phone-number of people we think are up to no good, like *gasp* not actually care or think about Israel that much, or *shock-horror-and-awe* date someone who isn't Jewish!
That's right! We, the true Children of Zion, must make sure our frivolous siblings in lands filled with temptation and free will and choice in how to be Jewish, know the true path of the Chosen People.
In the most fascist way possible.
Nothing says Homeland like Fatherland.
The ad, aimed at Israelis (hence the Hebrew) is supposed to invoke the feelings of sorrow and grief. The greyness and the music of flutes are themes found more often than not at our memorial ceremonies. Generally speaking, if there we are commemorating something of memorial it is going to be either for our Glorious Dead soldiers, or the victims of the Holocaust.
Israel needs the Diaspora.
It needs it mainly to have something to discount when it comes to Jewish identity.
As I said, the true Children of Zion (me), are the true Jews, all those others Out There, were not brave enough, strong enough in their Jewish conviction, or simply not truly Jewish, to come to Israel (Eretz Yisroel/Palestinah) and fight to create the state.
Or something ridiculous like that.
Surprise, Not all Jews appreciate this new campaign.
No! Really?! I'm so... unsurprised by this faux pas:
A public debate.
Yeah, a-huh, right. Israelis, especially ad campaigns, always like "arousing argument and emotions" with the notion that this is what grabs attention and provokes response and any response, is a good response.
When utterly disregarding the fact that an ad campaign of this nature makes it legitimate to give out information about people who didn't give their consent to this, it's no longer "public debate".
It's the basic democratic idea that people can live their lives how they chose, so long as no harm comes to another person.
We're the only democracy... how? Exactly?
If you're interested, you should read No Silent Holocaust on IsraLeft.
Ah well, such is the state of the State.
As most of you know, Israel presents itself as a Homeland and Nation-State to the Jewish people, all well and good in principle I suppose.
A problem exists though in the notion that Israel has any say about how Jews relate to the State of Israel, or if they were to consider it a Homeland of any kind.
A 2000 year Diaspora is not so easily diminished by the fact that the State exists for 61 years or that the ideal of a Nation came about around the same time as all the others... it was a Spring, if I'm not mistaken.
Let it not be said that Israel doesn't share the arrogance of its neighbours when it comes to upholding what is the correct way for Jews to be Jews, and telling them so.
This week a new campaign targeting Diaspora Jews who have been lost to assimilation was launched.
As can be read in the article linked, the campaign is in aid of MASA, which is a partnership between the Jewish Agency and the Israeli Government that helps bring young Diaspora Jews to Israel for academic programs and things like that.
The propaganda machine of what goes on in programs such as MASA and Birthright aside, the new campaign is by far worse than any I've ever seen.
The video of the ad linked here or viewable right here:
I've translated the Hebrew for the benefit of my non-Hebrew speaking readers:
Over 50% of young Jewish people abroad, assimilate and are lost to us.
Do you know a young Jewish person abroad?
Call the MASA [link[ project and together, we'll stregthen their ties to Israel, ensuring that we do not lose them.
MASA, a year in Israel, a lifetime of love.
Now, the problem isn't the fact that this campaign exists, much to my annoyance, the problem is with the idea that Israel has basically created a campaign in which it calls people to tattle to this agency about Jewish people who aren't "Jewish" enough.
And when I say tattle, I mean that the number given in the ad isn't for curious Diaspora Jews to call and inquire, no-no, it is for us, Israeli Jews, to call that number and give the email, facebook, blog, phone-number of people we think are up to no good, like *gasp* not actually care or think about Israel that much, or *shock-horror-and-awe* date someone who isn't Jewish!
That's right! We, the true Children of Zion, must make sure our frivolous siblings in lands filled with temptation and free will and choice in how to be Jewish, know the true path of the Chosen People.
In the most fascist way possible.
Nothing says Homeland like Fatherland.
The ad, aimed at Israelis (hence the Hebrew) is supposed to invoke the feelings of sorrow and grief. The greyness and the music of flutes are themes found more often than not at our memorial ceremonies. Generally speaking, if there we are commemorating something of memorial it is going to be either for our Glorious Dead soldiers, or the victims of the Holocaust.
Israel needs the Diaspora.
It needs it mainly to have something to discount when it comes to Jewish identity.
As I said, the true Children of Zion (me), are the true Jews, all those others Out There, were not brave enough, strong enough in their Jewish conviction, or simply not truly Jewish, to come to Israel (Eretz Yisroel/Palestinah) and fight to create the state.
Or something ridiculous like that.
Surprise, Not all Jews appreciate this new campaign.
No! Really?! I'm so... unsurprised by this faux pas:
A day after mounting a scare-tactic campaign to prevent the assimilation of Diaspora Jews, the Prime Minister's Office and Jewish Agency received some 200 calls, most of them reporting names of Jews living abroad.Emphasis mine
However, many callers also blasted the campaign - which describes assimilation as a "strategic national threat."
[...]
About 100 of the callers reported unmarried Jews aged 18-30 living in France, the United States and New Zealand. Callers also left their acquaintances' Facebook and Twitter names as well as email addresses so that MASA people could contact them.
The campaign also evoked many angry phone calls, some calling the campaign a "farce."
"Are we also supposed to report acquaintances who don't intend to have children?" one caller asked.
"We wanted to raise a public debate, even if it arouses argument and emotions," MASA's CEO Ayelet Shiloh-Tamir said Thursday.
A public debate.
Yeah, a-huh, right. Israelis, especially ad campaigns, always like "arousing argument and emotions" with the notion that this is what grabs attention and provokes response and any response, is a good response.
When utterly disregarding the fact that an ad campaign of this nature makes it legitimate to give out information about people who didn't give their consent to this, it's no longer "public debate".
It's the basic democratic idea that people can live their lives how they chose, so long as no harm comes to another person.
We're the only democracy... how? Exactly?
If you're interested, you should read No Silent Holocaust on IsraLeft.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 02:21 pm (UTC)*sigh* remind me again why I live here?
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 03:47 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 03:57 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 05:10 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 05:33 pm (UTC)Amirite?
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 05:40 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-07 05:03 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 05:34 pm (UTC)I keep reminding myself that I'm one of the good ones and shouldn't leave just because I'm told I'm one of the bad ones.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-07 05:10 am (UTC)You really are one of the good ones. I shudder to think what this country would look like without people like you.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 03:46 pm (UTC)i am gonna call the 1-800 number and report all my jewish friends!! then maybe finally israel will accept me
:)
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 05:35 pm (UTC):)
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 09:02 pm (UTC)This campaign feels depressingly inevitable.
I was just writing about how, as far as I'm concerned, Brooklyn and the Lower East Side of Manhattan are my homeland, too.
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 09:07 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 09:13 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 09:40 pm (UTC)Which just makes me want to escape from this country faster and marry a nice christian boy..
no subject
Date: 2009-09-06 09:46 pm (UTC)Seriously, there are different ways to be a Jew that has nothing to do with Orthodoxy and it's not Israel's job to monitor how other people do it.
*sigh*