Roman Polanski: It's worth repeating
Oct. 2nd, 2009 07:33 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
My last word on Roman Polanski, because honestly, what more can be said that hasn't.
I'll just repeat; the fact that he himself was a victim of violence, had a traumatic life and is a brilliant artist (yes, I love Rosemary's BabY and Chinatown) doesn't excuse the fact that he raped a child.
Drugged and raped a child.
Plead guilty in a plea bargain and then ran away because the deal looked as though it was about to fall through.
Art, power and money doesn't excuse the fact that he committed a crime against the body of a girl-child (btw, if it had been a 13 year old boy, I think we would be hearing a very different tune) and against the basic ideas that the law applies to every single one of us, no matter how clever, powerful and the fact that people really, really like the stuff we make.
For some reason, this is a hard concept to grasp for some people.
Art Does Not Excuse Rape.
These people make me happy for the amount of time I take to think about this issue.
This is not just about Roman Polanski. This is about the character of our society. The justice system is not perfect anywhere, but accountability and responsibility should not be taken for granted and the default of the oppressive patriarchy that has allowed Polanski to evade justice for so long should not be upheld.
It wounds and hurts too many of us to count.
N.B.
The Pianist was probably the worst movie he ever made.
Edited to Add:
In the comments
avgboojie says, quite rightly, that 13 years of age, isn't really a child:
The legal status of minors renders them as powerful as children in the eyes of the law, but not in their own eyed.
Her age and own perception doesn't make the rape and assault any less criminal or heinous.
The acknowledgement of this, is also of importance.
I'll just repeat; the fact that he himself was a victim of violence, had a traumatic life and is a brilliant artist (yes, I love Rosemary's BabY and Chinatown) doesn't excuse the fact that he raped a child.
Drugged and raped a child.
Plead guilty in a plea bargain and then ran away because the deal looked as though it was about to fall through.
Art, power and money doesn't excuse the fact that he committed a crime against the body of a girl-child (btw, if it had been a 13 year old boy, I think we would be hearing a very different tune) and against the basic ideas that the law applies to every single one of us, no matter how clever, powerful and the fact that people really, really like the stuff we make.
For some reason, this is a hard concept to grasp for some people.
Art Does Not Excuse Rape.
These people make me happy for the amount of time I take to think about this issue.
This is not just about Roman Polanski. This is about the character of our society. The justice system is not perfect anywhere, but accountability and responsibility should not be taken for granted and the default of the oppressive patriarchy that has allowed Polanski to evade justice for so long should not be upheld.
It wounds and hurts too many of us to count.
N.B.
The Pianist was probably the worst movie he ever made.
Edited to Add:
In the comments
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
I want to stress one important point: a 13 year old girl is not "a child".
Sorry. I don't know of any definition by which a 13 year old girl is a child. 13 year old girls are almost always post-puberty, sometimes (perhaps often) have active sex lives of their own, and while they are considered minors by law, they are not children (for instance, a person having sex with a 13 year old is not a pedophile, since these focus on pre-puberty children).
I think referring to a 13 year old as "a child" (something which is most probably done because "raped a child" sounds far more shocking than "raped an adolescent" or "raped a young woman") is disrespectful towards the 13-year-old person, disowning them of any right to be considered a semi-grown person with free will and any capability for adult reasoning.
The legal status of minors renders them as powerful as children in the eyes of the law, but not in their own eyed.
Her age and own perception doesn't make the rape and assault any less criminal or heinous.
The acknowledgement of this, is also of importance.