eumelia: (Default)
Eumelia ([personal profile] eumelia) wrote2009-10-07 03:45 pm

More Mini-Truthes (disapproval edition)

I was going to write about the Goldstone Report and how Israel, once again, managed to avoid any kind of accountability for their actions in Gaza.
This UN fact finding mission had strong words about Hamas' conduct as well, calling the firing of Qassam rockets war-crimes.
This is something that is often omitted, mainly because Goldstone puts the onus onto Israel, seeing as Israel did kill 1,500 Palestinians, the majority of them civilians.

The main conclusion I've come to in this whole affair is that the UN, once again, proved itself to be the most redundant and irrelevant organisation in the world.

So much potential UN, your execution of anything leaves much to be desired. You're good at reporting things and writing them down, but acting upon it.
Not so much.

Can't help that the US pretty much bullies you into submission time and time again when it comes to Israel.
Israel, of course, also bullied Mahmoud Abbas into deferring talks about the report, thus turning the President of the PA and head of Fatah into a collaborator.

Strong words, but that's the way he is viewed at the moment, at least, that's the only way I can think the Palestinians would view him at the moment.
There are demands that he quit. There is of course backtracking, much backtracking.
The people are feeling the leadership.
Not really, no.
I have to say, even at my most cynical, because I think the PA is as corrupt as any other government only doesn't have the power or money to cover it up, I didn't expect this.
Goldstone was the PA's golden ticket at getting something, world recognition.
Israel blew it too, by not co-operating and using the power of the all-mighty Hasbarah to discredit Justice Goldstone; our own reactionary and paranoiac response to to the fact finding mission, headed by a self-identified Zionist, a man who has headed numerous Israeli academic boards and has Israeli family, has driven the report out of Israel's (or Palestine's) control.
Because now Lybia is taking the task of holding talks about the report.

Who said Israel and Palestine deserved each other?

It is worth mentioning that this month is the anniversary of the October 2000 Events. There are currently riots in Jerusalem (I'm happy the J-Lem contingent of my family is not there at the 'mo) hence keeping out Sheikh Ra'ad Salah for the month.
September-October are always tense due to the High Holidays and the intensifying security forces around the Western Wall and the Al-Aqsa mosque.
It doesn't help that said security forces are racist and not shy about it.
That U.S Jews feel they have the right to Jerusalem more than any other religion that holds it holy, because yeah, that's what's happening at the moment too.
"It's mine!", "No, It's mine!!"
If there was going to be a massive earthquake, let it be there.

Regardless of who is to blame, this is just a taste of things to come.
The Palestinians will have Intifada vs 0.3, the IDF will once again head into the depth of the West Bank, probably "re-conquer" the Gaza Strip, while feeding us (Israelis) the tripe of "they brought on themselves", "we have no choice", etc. etc.

Same ole tune, shiny new instruments.

More on this and digression thereof in a little while. This should give you all something to chew on for a bit.

[identity profile] whereisjoy.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 02:21 pm (UTC)(link)
I actually think that this time the UN did about everything right and Israel and to a lesser extent the PA is to blame. Can't blame the UN for that fact that Israel just refuses to act as though international law applies to it in any way.

Also, to call the Goldstone report the PA's ticket to getting recognition is a little much. They've had that particular ticket - UN truth-telling - for ages. The relevant resolutions and such go back to before the PA. Doesn't seem to Palestinians much good, and not because for the PA's mishandling.

[identity profile] eumelia.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 06:09 pm (UTC)(link)
The UN did what it always does. Report on things and not do much to change. They always act after-the-fact and are under the US thumb seeing as the headquarters are in NYC.
I have a hard time viewing them as anything other than a toothless... whatever that pops up when a finger needs a-wagging.

I think the PA has some mishandling on it's head, but that's hardly the main reason for the resolutions not doing much good. Israel has the PA by the short and curlies and that's pretty much it.

[identity profile] whereisjoy.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 06:15 pm (UTC)(link)
Totally agree. But the onerous is still totally on Israel. Blaming the UN obscures the issue.

I used to be really frustrated with the UN, but then I started working with them myself. And while they are everything you say they are, the people who were with the UN in Palestine are mostly PALESTINIANS. So blaming them just started to feel really sick. It's still Israel and the US. Those are who I'm going to wag my finger at. We actually do need someone who's monitoring and reporting on stuff. I'm not an apologist for them AT ALL, but that the Goldstone debacle is Bibi's fault. Surprise, surprise.

[identity profile] eumelia.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 06:18 pm (UTC)(link)
[nods] that's a good point.

And yeah, Goldstone is totally on Bibi (though I'm still agog at Abbas, I shouldn't be... but I am *sigh*).

[identity profile] whereisjoy.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 06:21 pm (UTC)(link)
oh dude, I have personal problem with Abbas. Pissed with him, I am, though I don't say that in public. It's not my business since I'm not Palestinian and it's not like my government will let them have a democracy.... any way.

[identity profile] hemlock-sholes.livejournal.com 2009-10-07 10:06 pm (UTC)(link)
[Tongue-in-cheek mode activated]
So you're saying that the people whose jobs depend on the Palestinians remaining refugees are Palestinians themselves?

Interesting...

Also, the USA donates more money to the UN than any other, so I assume that's one of the reasons it has a small say in what the UN does.

Don't take me too seriously :)

[identity profile] whereisjoy.livejournal.com 2009-10-09 12:18 am (UTC)(link)
Har har. :-)